How to choose the best leather tote bag

Believe it or not, the tote bag originated out of necessity in the 1940s as a means to carry ice from the car to the freezer. However, by the time the 1960s rolled around, the tote had risen from humble beginnings to a fashionable, sought-after accessory and has stayed that way ever since.

Many designers and brands, including Billy Tannery, have put their own stamp on the tote bag. Features of the original tote prevail but new elements, fabrics, and patterns have emerged over time. For those looking to express their personality with their bag choice, the variety is great, but it does mean that choosing the best leather tote bag for your style and circumstances can feel like a daunting task. Don’t worry though, this guide will talk you through pinpointing what makes the best leather tote bag so that you can have it slung over your shoulder in no time.

What is a tote bag?

While tote bags can often appear simple in design, it is the spacious construction and usability that make them a much-loved accessory. Tote bags are larger in comparison to typical leather handbags and are often unfastened, allowing for easy access to their contents. They have parallel handles that are attached on each side of the main body pouch and can have extra features such as outside slip pockets or interior compartments.



Tote bags are designed for versatility and convenience. They are suitable for carrying a variety of items ranging from daily essentials and groceries to work-related materials and everything you need for an impromptu night away.

Are leather tote bags worth it?

Absolutely, yes! A well-made leather tote bag is an investment that can last for many years, even with regular use. Leather is renowned for its durability and timeless appeal. Unlike synthetic materials, leather becomes more supple and develops a unique patina over time, adding to its charm and character. The longevity and classic style of leather tote bags make them a worthwhile addition to any wardrobe.

How do I choose a leather tote bag?

Selecting the perfect leather tote bag can seem overwhelming, given the plethora of options available. However, choosing the right tote bag involves focusing on key factors such as:

•  Functionality

• Size

• Style

• Durability

• Price

• Must-have features

That way, you can narrow down your choices and find the perfect bag that suits your needs and personal style. For example, if choosing a work tote bag, you might look for one that’s large enough to fit your laptop, lunch and daily essentials while also being robust enough to stand up to the daily commute on public transport. You’ll likely want it to be highly functional while also looking professional but still be stylish enough that it’ll look the part at after work social events.

Functionality

Think about how you intend to use the tote bag. For office use, a tote bag with a detachable shoulder strap and a compartment large enough for a laptop might be ideal. For weekend trips, a zip tote could provide added security for your belongings.

Size

The size of the tote bag is crucial. For daily use, a medium-sized bag that can hold your essentials without being too bulky is probably preferable. However, if you need to carry larger items or plan to use the bag for travel, opt for a larger size. Our leather tote bag has a 25-litre volume, making it a great choice for most uses.

Style

Style is a personal preference and should reflect your taste. Classic designs in neutral colours can be versatile and timeless, while more contemporary styles with bold colours or unique features can make a statement. Look at the intricate details such as the hardware and stitching as these all play into the overall aesthetic of the piece. Also, remember that you can change the vibe of a tote bag with a few additions. For example, you can tie a patterned silk scarf around one handle or attach a colourful luggage tag.

Price

Leather tote bags come in a wide range of prices but determining your budget before you start your search can help. Remember, a lower cost can feel like you’re getting a bargain, but it may mean that the quality of the leather and craftsmanship of the tote bag just isn’t as good. In contrast, a higher initial cost can be justified by a bag's durability and longevity if the materials and construction are top-tier.

Longevity

Investing in a high-quality leather tote bag means considering its longevity. Look for bags with reinforced stitching, high-quality leather, and sturdy hardware to ensure they will withstand regular use over time.

Strength

The strength of the bag is important, especially if you plan to carry heavy items. Check the weight capacity and ensure that the handles and straps are robust enough to support your needs.

Colour

Choose a colour that complements your wardrobe and suits your lifestyle. Neutral colours like black, brown, and tan are versatile and can match almost any outfit. If you prefer something a little different, consider a forest green or rich navy instead.

Finish

The finish of the leather can affect the bag's look and feel. Smooth finishes offer a sleek and polished appearance, while textured finishes like pebbled or distressed leather can add interest. At Billy Tannery, we lean into the unique markings of every piece of full-grain leather we use meaning that no two bags are exactly the same.

What are the key features to look for in a high-quality luxury tote bag?

When discussing high-quality luxury tote bags, the considerations go beyond general practicality and extend into attention to detail. Here are key features that set a luxury leather tote apart from a standard high-quality one:

• Handcrafted excellence: True luxury totes are often handmade or hand-finished by skilled artisans, ensuring a level of detail and craftsmanship that mass production can't match.

• Precision: Look for meticulous stitching, perfectly aligned seams, and uniform edge painting which are all signs of expert craftsmanship.

• Premium, responsibly sourced leather: The best luxury totes use full-grain leather that are carefully selected, ethically sourced, and treated with environmentally conscious tanning methods for a rich, lasting finish.

• Exquisite hardware & finishing touches: Solid brass, gold-plated, or palladium hardware, custom clasps, and embossed brand details elevate a luxury tote’s design and durability.

• Limited production: Many luxury brands produce limited runs and offer bespoke services, adding an element of rarity and exclusivity.

• Lining & interior details: High-end totes often feature premium fabric or suede linings, leather-trimmed pockets, and perfectly finished interior seams. Our totes are lined with quality cotton drill sourced from Manchester’s oldest textile company.

• Sustainability & ethical craftsmanship: Luxury is increasingly defined by responsible production methods, from vegetable tanning to fair-wage artisan work.

• Investment value: A luxury tote isn’t just a purchase - it’s an investment. The best ones retain or even appreciate in value due to their enduring style and desirability.

What is the best leather tote bag?

The best leather tote bag is ultimately the one that fits your individual needs, lifestyle, and personal preferences. While one person may prioritise an ageless, structured design for work, another may prefer a soft, slouchy tote for casual everyday use. That said, here are some key factors to consider when finding the best leather tote bag for you:

Suits your personal style – Whether you love minimalism, classic elegance, or bold, statement pieces, your tote should reflect your aesthetic.

• Has timeless appeal: A well-designed leather tote won’t fall out of fashion, making it a long-term investment.

• Made from high-quality, traceable leather: Ethically sourced, full-grain leather ensures durability and a beautiful patina over time.

• Practical and functional for your needs: Its size, compartments, and whether it fits your must-haves is important.

• Comfortable to carry: Look for sturdy, well-proportioned handles and straps that sit comfortably on your shoulders.

• Versatile for different occasions: A great leather tote transitions effortlessly from work to weekends and even travel.

• Crafted with expert craftsmanship: Strong stitching, quality hardware, and attention to detail elevate both aesthetics and durability.

• Ethical and sustainable production: If sustainability matters to you, look for brands that use eco-friendly tanning processes and fair labour practices.

• Good value for money: The best tote bag isn’t necessarily the most expensive. It’s one that offers longevity, style, and quality at a fair price.

Ultimately, purchasing a leather tote bag is a decision you won't regret. With the right choice, you will have a stylish, durable, and versatile accessory that will serve you for years to come.

Seeking something different? Browse all of our leather bags and we are sure you’ll find just what you’re looking for.